Portfolio Peer Critique Rating Page Template

---Put your name here---

What is the complete URL of the portfolio?

Who is the owner of the portfolio?


Instructions:

  1. Rate the items below using the following scale:
    1. Needs Improvement (1pt)
    2. Standard/Adequate (2pts)
    3. Excellent/Outstanding (3pts)
  2. Include an example to support your rating.
  3. At the end of the critique add up all of the points you have awarded to this portfolio.

 

1. First Impression of Portfolio Home or Opening Page

Is it totally clear who the owner is, what s/he offers or is looking for, what will be found at this site, does it look like the site of a professional, and does the visitor feel encouraged and invited to look further, is the load time appropriate?

    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

 

2. Organization and navigation.

Does the organization of the pages and site content make sense, can the visitor easily find the important elements, and navigate the various pages easily, do all the links work as expected, are the download times for the various graphics and images on all pages appropriate.

  1. Needs Improvement
  2. Standard/Adequate
  3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

3. First impression of the resume.

Is it immediately and totally clear who the owner of this resume is, and how to make contact? Does the resume state what s/he offers or is looking for? Does the resume have a professional look and feel, and does the visitor feel encouraged to look more closely, is the load time appropriate?

    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

4. Does the resume contain the required elements listed below:

  • Name and Contact Info
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

  • Employment Objective
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

  • Technical Skills Section
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

  • Accomplishments (Experience) Section
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

  • Education Section
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

     

5. Appearance & Readability

Do the Visual Formatting and Page Layouts look professional and do they support and enhance the content?

  • How well are the following elements used: background and foreground colors, images, font faces, sizes and colors, etc?
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

  • Is the text concise and well written, and sufficient for clarity? Are there any Grammar, Spelling, or Typographical errors?
    1. Needs Improvement
    2. Standard/Adequate
    3. Excellent/Outstanding

Give at least one concrete example, from the Portfolio, that supports your rating:

 

Overall Rating: _______ points