Children
have superheroes, and adults may need heroes too. As long as we
remember they're human and fallible, our heroes can teach
and inspire us, broadening our vision and deepening our insight.
My heroes include Albert Einstein, Jerry Garcia, Noam Chomsky, and my mother,
along with other famous and non-famous people who've helped improve my
soul.
I have
three heroes for a healthy diet: John McDougall and Dean Ornish (both
M.D.s), and John Robbins. Each has authored several books.
All recommend low-fat, vegetarian, whole foods to counteract the epidemics
of heart disease, diabetes, cancer, and other "diseases of affluence" that
stem largely from rich foods and processed foods. Ornish's research
has proven that heart disease is reversible with diet and lifestyle changes.
Robbins is passionate about animals suffering in "factory farms."
McDougall sticks with human health concerns; his clearly written and carefully
researched books are loaded with references to studies published in major
medical journals.
Distancing
himself from longhaired fringe elements of society, McDougall barely uses
the word "vegetarian," proclaiming that he himself eats turkey on Thanksgiving.
"Feast foods" are fine (he says) when eaten on rare occasions by healthy
people, but health is destroyed when we consume them constantly.
McDougall sees his diet as conservative medical therapy, referring to recommended
foods as "health supporting."
Some
vegetarians have a horrendous diet, gorging on high-fat dairy and eggs
along with oily food and processed junk food. McDougall excludes
milk and eggs, so his diet is not just vegetarian (no meat) but is also
"vegan" (no animal foods at all, pronounced "vee-gun"). He also excludes
vegetable oils, which are highly concentrated derivatives from the original
foods and are 100% pure fat. The ultimate food addiction is often
to fat: vegetarians may load up on cheese, vegans on oil. The
small amount of fat we truly need is easily obtained from whole foods,
and protein is no problem if the diet is varied and includes beans, grains,
or potatoes.
Years
of propaganda (such as the "Four Food Groups" and Dairy Council
"educational" materials in our schools) have convinced
us that our protein needs are much higher than they actually are.
Our greatest protein need is in infancy, but human breast milk is only
5% protein, while 21% of the calories in cow's milk are protein.
(Whole cow's milk is 49% fat. "2%" milk sounds low-fat only because
they count the water; its calories are 28% fat and 28% protein. Skim
milk is 41% protein.) Our body's greatly preferred source of energy
is carbohydrate. Excess protein strains the liver and kidneys; calcium
is robbed from the bones to neutralize the acidic pH of protein waste products,
and this calcium is often lost in the urine. Years of "negative calcium
balance" lead to osteoporosis, which is epidemic among older women in the
U.S. Our high milk consumption certainly does not appear to be preventing
osteoporosis. Cows themselves, along with elephants, build very strong
bones eating nothing but vegetable foods after they are weaned. Cow's
milk is also a frequent allergen and is strongly implicated in childhood
ear infections, which caused my parents and I to suffer through many surgeries
and left me
with a permanent hearing loss. Regardless of what
the ads say, milk is not a health food.
A diet
like McDougall's may seem so foreign that some people won't try it, despite
its phenomenal benefits for both long term health and current quality of
life. Changing to a low-fat whole foods diet may require several
weeks or months of learning new skills in buying and preparing food, but
the benefits will last a lifetime. McDougall's books (along with
those of Ornish and Robbins) are packed with shopping and cooking tips,
including countless recipes. Whole grains and whole grain breads
and pastas, vegetables, beans, and potatoes are easily combined and prepared
with herbs and spices into an enormous variety of luscious, tasty dishes
that are satisfying and filling. Fat-free apple crisp might make
a delicious dessert, while popcorn, fruits, and guilt-free cookies are
among endless possibilities for snacks. Since "the fat you eat is
the fat you wear," most people can eat all they want, and body weight will
gradually normalize on its own. One of Ornish's books is actually
called "Eat More, Weigh Less."
Sometimes
we wait for a major shock to goad us into action. People contracting
lung cancer often quit smoking; those suffering heart attacks may change
their diet. Why wait? Dr. Ornish says that those who make positive
changes not only protect their future health, but also feel much better
pretty quickly. Why not change now?
One
powerful source of inertia stems from the dietary habits of others and
of our culture. I'm frequently offered rich food; refusing it sometimes
necessitates delicate social steps, because the "breaking of bread" together
is a basic expression of human community. I'm improving my ability
to tactfully say no. It's important to me not to be a food bigot
on a crusade, but nevertheless to quietly avoid swallowing things that
make me feel lousy or undermine my health. McDougall has many practical
strategies in this area.
For
some, additional motivation for change may come from considering the larger
consequences of our food choices. Intensive animal-based agriculture
is incredibly wasteful and polluting. According to the University
of California publication "Soil and Water," an acre of prime land can produce
40,000 pounds of potatoes or 30,000 pounds of carrots, but only 250 pounds
of beef. Over 70% of the U.S. grain harvest is fed to animals; lots
of fossil fuel is used to grow that grain, and pesticides applied to the
monoculture crops pollute our water. It takes 10-15 pounds of grain
to produce a pound of meat, while the rest of the grain energy is dissipated
as heat or converted to manure. A moderate amount of animal waste
spread on a field nourishes the soil, but mountains of manure in one place
cause serious pollution problems. One "farm" in Utah can produce
millions of pigs per year along with more manure than the human waste from
the city of Los Angeles.
We are
insulated from the way meat is produced today. Many of us may have
no problem with the simple idea of killing an animal, but would be repulsed
to see how animals suffer through life and death in factory farms.
Animal cruelty laws in the U.S. exclude "standard agricultural practices,"
but anyone who treated a cat or dog the way we routinely treat billions
of chickens and pigs would suffer both prosecution and the collective disgust
of the community. George Bernard Shaw said that "custom will reconcile
people to any atrocity." Along with moving testimonies about the
character and qualities of farm animals, John Robbins describes factory
farming in excruciating detail, and points out that the healthiest diet
for us is (not surprisingly) also best for other creatures and for the
planet as a whole.
Robbins
also contemplates the spiritual nature of food--the value of giving thanks
to the earth or a higher power before eating, and of eating slowly and
sharing the experience with loved ones when possible. It's important
to enjoy our food, savoring each bite and chewing it thoroughly, not taking
another bite until the previous one is swallowed. Not only does this
improve digestion and avert the tendency we sometimes have to stuff ourselves,
but it also puts us into deeper contact with our food and with the larger
whole from which it comes.
My three
nutrition heroes continue to inspire me. John Robbins started an
organization called "EarthSave" that now has chapters
throughout the world. Dean
Ornish and John McDougall continue to reach large audiences
with lifesaving information. These are worthy heroes who have helped
me steadily improve my diet for 15 years. Now I feel ready for a
major step forward: to make a committment to myself to put only those
things into my body that I believe will support health. Why not,
and why not now?
Please see
my earlier article, Food For Thought, for some internet
links regarding nutrition and food production.