PREDESTINATION vs FREE WILL For Travelers: Are We Doomed Or Just Unprepared?
We're all doomed. And we all know it. The world's shortest dramatic poem goes, "Born - Suffered - Died." What is life but a term of intermittant pain and suffering, followed by extinction? That's the program. "Life's a bitch, then you die." Many theologies offer unsubstantiated hopes of some sort of AFTERLIFE (click here). Do you adhere to such wishful thinking? Do you feel better? Whatever.
Tied to concerns of life and afterlife is the question of human agency — are we free to do and think whatever we wish, or are we controlled by forces beyond our ken, by biology and environment and even invisible and forces? Does some great spirit play us like chess pawns, determining our every move, or at least the impetus of our lifestyle?
As a traveler you may ask, "What's this to me?" Why, it's EVERYTHING! Your view on PREDESTINATION vs FREE WILL colors not just your life, but how and why and where you will journey as well. It is THE most important consideration.
VIEWPOINTS
The extreme FREE WILL position assumes that you are responsible for everything you do. You must make all your own preparations, assemble your own agendas and gear, make your own bookings, use your best judgement in your journeys and communications. And, except for unforeseeable natural occurrances (mostly seismic), you have nothing and nobody but yourself to blame for whatever ensues.
The extreme PREDESTINATION view holds that invisible friend(s) and/or forces control you completely. Is your god a pill? "Everything you do, think or say / is in the pill you took today." Whether or not you make plans and preparations, gather gear and goodies, treat yourself and others well or poorly, has nothing to do with your own will — it's all part of a Greater Plan. And NOTHING is your fault, except as you fail to accomplish your part in that Plan — and your 'failure' may also be part of the Plan, and thus not your fault. You are invulnerable.
JOURNEYS
Let's see how ordinary and extraordinary journeys play out between these polar viewpoints. You decide (or your invisible friend forces you) to take a December vacation to Thailand. You do (or don't) learn to speak a little Thai; you gather some beachware, and maybe (or maybe not) some prophylactics and cosmetics; and off you go. You hit the beach, get tanned and fit, get sexually lucky (or maybe not), get stuffed, etc. Then the earth quakes and the tsunami strikes. Whether you survive or not, it's not your fault. It's either a matter of luck, or it's Allah's (or Jehovah's or Kali's or B0B's) will.
Maybe instead of the pleasure-palace beaches, you go instead to the central highlands of New Guinea. Prepared or not, there you are amid high tropical mountains and deep foggy valleys and immense steep jungles and tribes of cannibals. Cannibals? Ah, you end up in a stew pot; or maybe your new friends offer you a serving of someone else and you get CJD, the human equivalent of Mad Cow. The FREE WILLer has only theirself to blame, for venturing into cannibal territory. To the PREDESTINATIONer it's all part of a divine plan — the locals need food and you're it.
Maybe you take your vacation in Yucatan instead, in the back-country of the jungle. You are offered a thatch-roof hut for sleeping. The FREE WILL guy or gal says, "Thanks, but I'll stay in my tent instead." The PREDESTINATIONer says, "This is providential! Yes, thank you for the hut!" and then scorpions fall out of the thatching. Ouch. Who knew better? Are you fated to be be stung by scorpions? Which part of the Greater Plan is that?
GUIDELINES
You'll be safer if you act as though FREE WILL were operative. Prepare meticulously — you're either being prudent, or your invisible friend requires your efforts in order to achieve The Plan. Tread lightly upon the Earth, either becase you're environmentally responsible or because Isis wants you to. Take all due precautions, whether you're your own best safety net, or because Jesus has uses for you later.
If you truly believe in PREDESTINATION, nothing you do or don't do really matters. At least, you can't change things by wanting to. Follow all your whims; go as you are; screw whatever is available; burn down forests and heretical churches and icons of iniquity; eat and drink and smoke and snort and inject whatever you want, or abstain — it's all in the blueprint. Whatever happens is meant to happen. Your every action and thought is an expression of divine will. Go with it.
Or maybe you're a sneaky little predestination hypocrite. You SAY that it's all {JHWH}'s plan, but you make your own vain plans, take your own puny precautions. O ye of little faith... you're damned to Hell.
So we're all doomed (expect for reincarnation), at least until the immortality machines go online, and then we'll likely encounter other dooms. The only variables of doom are WHEN and HOW. What path(s) will you take to your doom(s)? What will happen when (not if) you get there? Will you have fun along the way? Will you itch and drip and twitch and rip? Consideration of all these matters can only make you a better traveler. Or a more nervous or sanctimonious or intrepid traveler. Whatever.
|