Sebastopol United Methodist Church

500 North Main Street
Sebastopol, CA 95472-3498
Phone: (707) 823-7971 Fax: 823-5841

 

"To know, grow and show the transforming love of God"

On the Journey...
Serving...
Changing...
Including...
Supporting...
Creating...

Worship Opportunities
From the Pastor
Upcoming Events
Outreach Programs
History of Seb UMC
Map and Directions
Stained Glass Memorial Window
Sebastopol UMC Staff
E-mail Sebastopol UMC
Other Links





Over 135 Years of Faithful Witness:
A History of the Sebastopol United Methodist Church

Class meetings and preachings were held in homes, dance halls, school buildings, etc., before our first church was built. The Reverend George Clifford, who was assigned to Santa Rosa Methodist Church in 1866, conducted services in the Crist Dance Hall in Sebastopol until he could secure a lot and build a church. The land was donated by Dr. Plunkett, a woman doctor who ran a home for wayward girls near our present Epworthian Hall site. The trustees of Green Valley Methodist Church, our mother church, signed the deed and saw that our pulpit was filled. The wooden building, a cozy 40 ft. by 60 ft., was completed in 1867. It had one aisle down the center with wooden pews on each side and was heated by a wood stove. Sebastopol was part of a circuit which at times included Guerneville, Forestville, Green Valley, Bloomfield and Occidental; services were held semimonthly. Lorenzo L. Fellers was assigned to this circuit from 1882-84.

1889-1892 Rev. Lorr M. Ewing, our first pastor, was a cowboy preacher, rough and ready. In 1891 Bloomfield was added to his charge and remained with Sebastopol until 1895. The first bell given to the church was in honor of William Hotle's father. At the first meeting of the Methodist women on May 27, 1890 a name was chosen for the group. It was decided that only the initials should be made public. Anyone desiring to know the name must become a member. The imposing title was the L.B.& S. Society, Ladies Beneficial and Social Society.

1892-1893 Rev. Frank L. Tuttle In 1892, Mrs. Beeson, Luther Burbank's sister, who lived on Burbank Experimental Farm, invited the youth of the church to her home for prayer meetings and organized a study class for young people called the Epworth League. There were a few other Epworth League organizations in other churches at that time, but we were one of the earliest. There were seven original members including president, William Hotle. On May 15, 1889 the District Epworth League was organized with Mary D. Hotle as president. The youth sometimes came in horse and buggy from as far as 20 or 25 miles.

1893-1896 Thomas R. Bartley was reserved but loved by all the children. His wife was famous for big onion pies.

1896-1898 Rev. J.C. Bolster Soon after Rev. Bolster was appointed the church burned down. The Reverend boarded in downtown Sebastopol and preached in a large tent until the second church was completed. This church had gas lamps. The first service was held on August 18, 1897. At that time the pastor's salary was $700. There were 121 church members, 19 probationers, and 160 scholars in Sunday School.

1898-1899 Rev. G.M. Meese, his wife Harriet, and the children all sang trios.

1899-1901 Rev. Thomas B. Palmer was a diligent student of the Word and presented deep insights to the people in his preaching.

1901-1903 Rev. Edwin H. Smith was an Occidental boy. This was his first charge. He had paperweights made with his picture and the second church, showing rail and bank where our cement wall is now.

1903-1905 Rev. Fred R. Winsor was a good singer and a great preacher. His carefully prepared sermons, earnestly delivered, and his spirituality made him a favorite speaker. He was called to preach in many other communities. When the railroad went through town in 1904-05 the church hill was cut down. This left the church with a $3,544.57 bill for the building of a wall around the property and for paving. The Ladies Aid took over the debt about 1923. For years they served lunch to the Rotary in the Chamber of Commerce building every Friday. Lois White was chairperson of this project. The debt was paid off in 1938 when Mildred Fredricks was president.

1905-1909 Rev. Whitman Philo Stanley The first parsonage was moved to Florence Avenue (rolled on logs) and a new parsonage was built (now called Asbury House). Several trees had to be sacrificed, causing much anguish and controversy. Mrs. Palmer, wife of Rev. Thomas B. Palmer, gave land in back of the parsonage for a right of way. Our church was first incorporated in January, 1906.

1909-1911 Rev. James L. Case was energetic and enthusiastic.

1911-1916 Rev. William P. Rankin By 1913 the second church had just been remodeled for $1,000 and Epworthian Hall erected at a cost of $2,000. Rev. Rankin, a strong advocate of prohibition, did quite a bit of speaking on the "wet" versus "dry" question. He was even warned to stay off the streets at night. On October 22, 1914, the church was set on fire (also Occidental Methodist and the two Congregational churches in Green Valley and Sebastopol. A fire at the Catholic church was found in time to save the church). When the streetcar came down from Monte Rio about 2 a.m. a member of the crew saw the blaze. As the crew rushed up to the church they could smell kerosene. The church burned to the ground and the fir trees around the church were flaming torches that could be seen for miles. The "wets" were given credit for the burning. Epworthian Hall was badly damaged, but not destroyed. It was fully covered, but only $2,000 insurance was carried on the church. The congregation met in Lincoln Hall (a large hall behind the present library site where revivals were held) while rebuilding the hall, and then services were held in Epworthian Hall. The cost of the new edifice was $11,500. On October 12, 1915 the new Spanish Colonial Revival church was dedicated by Bishop Edwin Holt Hughes with an audience of 600. The organ, the largest type reed organ made, was placed in the middle of the choir loft. It was donated by Mary Hotle's father, D.S. Dickson, who died three days later. A splendid 42" Blymer bell was placed in the tower of the church by Mr. and Mrs. William Hotle in memory of their little son, William Francis, and was used for the first time to call our people to the sunrise service.

1916-1918 Rev. A. O. Amundson was called in 1918 to be a chaplain in the World War.

1918-1920 Rev. Frederick C. Conaway The hitching racks had been moved to just below our cement wall on the Healdsburg Avenue side where the Women's Christian Temperance Union had erected a watering trough for thirsty horses. The Women's Christian Temperance Union played an important part in our church history, and our women have at times been very active in the work against liquor, tobacco, and drug addiction.

1920-1924 Mahlon B. Young started printing our first bulletin in the church basement. He put on programs in which he whistled. He attracted youth and included them in all the church activities.

1924-1942 Rev. James Phillips was a quiet, hardworking man, with a good sense of humor, who was loved by all in the community. The young people enjoyed hearing stories of his early years as a miner in England. In 1934 the Epworth League made a gift quilt for Rev. and Mrs. Phillips with 20 signatures to a block. There were 400 people that had signed their names at a cost of $.20 per name. Lillian Christie (Langford), president of the League, did most of the embroidering.

Frank Fellers (son of Lorenzo Fellers) was counselor for the Methodist Youth Fellowship (MYF) and was District and Conference president. In 1929 he made an efficient trailer that could be used for cooking. Frank took this trailer from one Epworth League Institute to another (and later MYF camps) during the summers until 1951 when it burned down at Shasta.

In 1935 the church had 316 members, Sunday School 265, Nursery Roll, 38. Value of the building was $23,000. The Golden Rule class was organized in October, 1938 with 25 charter members including Gertrude Roberts, Pearl Welch, John and Helen Crump, Joe and Myrtle Seavers, Elmer and Betty Hankins, and Clifton and Marjorie Schultz. They were responsible for starting the nursery during church services.

When the Methodist Episcopal Church, the Methodist Episcopal Church South, and the Methodist Protestant Church united on June 15, 1939, the organization of women's work changed. The Ladies Aid had cared for parish needs, while the Women's Home and the Women's Foreign Missionary Societies had ministered in their respective fields. With unification the Women's Society of Christian Service assumed control of women's activities. The WSCS in our church held its first meeting on September 5, 1940 with 102 charter members.

About 1936 the class that Mr. William Hotle had in Sunday School started our traditional Mother's Day bouquets, which has continued to this day. The bouquets originally went to mothers 80 years of age or older, but later were given to all women 80 or over.

Church dinners and Easter breakfasts were held in the church basement before Epworthian Hall was moved to its present location. Chairs had to be carried down from the Hall to the basement for dinners. Sunday School classes were held in Epworthian Hall with dividers between the classes. Plays were produced for the church and the community. There was a stage in the Hall. Mrs. Marguerite Mahoney was the director and Will Roberts was the stage manager.

1942-1948 Rev. Stephen C. Thomas worked especially with Methodist Youth Fellowship. He was a small man who drove a Ford and all you could see was his hat. He drove around and gathered the kids for Sunday evening MYF. Rev. Thomas was the one who urged the church to begin a Methodist Men's group. Bill Martinson was the first president of the Redwood Empire District Methodist Men. The men sponsored a troop of Boy Scouts for many years (Troop #28, Sebastopol). In 1945 the Methodist Men began one of the outstanding events in our church, the Men's Easter Breakfast. There were many challenging and inspiring speakers from all walks of life. The breakfast was cooked by the Wesleyan Service Guild for many years, then others took that responsibility, with the MYF helping to serve and clean up. It was a wonderful time of fellowship and working together.

1948-1952 Rev. James Alvin Crawford had a tremendously talented musical family. Rev. Crawford was also an artist. Mable Crawford was active in the primary department. The Kumdubbles group began in 1949 and continued for 25 years. It was a wonderful group for Christian fellowship of married couples, including some who were not active in regular church activities. There was much sharing of parental lore, special outings, missionary support, and just plain fun.

The WCSC began a Christmas Tea in 1950, during the time that Mariam Hotle Burdo was president and Eunice Martinson was vice president. For several years the entire program was held in Epworthian Hall. But when more tables were put in, it was too crowded, so the program was held in the sanctuary and the tea tables were in the Hall.

1952-1958 Rev. Virgil Wesley Jackson He had valley fever. The pulpit was remodeled with wings on each end so that the congregation couldn't see how much Rev. Jackson moved around and kicked. He was so friendly and at ease in all situations, he couldn't walk down to the post office without a half dozen people asking him to have coffee. Nellie Jackson was a good cook and not afraid to wear overalls. On November 22, 1954 C.A. Miller deeded his house to the church to use for the parsonage (our present parsonage) and the old parsonage was used for Sunday School rooms. In 1956 Charge Conference records show a membership of 409 and a Church School enrollment of 494, with an average attendance of 207. In 1955 the new organ was installed, donated by the Burdo family.

1958-1966 Rev. Lewis Whitehead was born in Bolivia where his parents were missionaries. Lewis' father, Irving Whitehead, was an important part of our church, always helping at all the church activities. The shut-ins were inspired by the Sunday sermons which he took to them on tape. All ages enjoyed his witty and wise sayings on the blackboard in the Berean Room (the current choir room).

A loan for $75,000 was obtained from the Bank of Sonoma County on March 1, 1963. The new educational wing was completed on September 25, 1963. Epworthian Hall was moved from next to the church to its present location and a kitchen and restrooms were added. The total cost of the project was over $125,000. At that time the property was valued at $206,000. The consecration was held January 12, 1964. Participating ministers included Bishop Donald H. Tippett, the district superintendent, and three former pastors.

In the early sixties Lyle Leake made the cross in back of the pulpit. Pete Coleman made the altar rail. At that time the pulpit area was rearranged and the front pews were removed, replaced by a straight railing. Allen White made our baptismal font. John Lundberg made the communion table. The Kumdubble men removed the pews and replaced them after carpet was installed. In 1966 we held our first all-church family camp. For several years we met at Mt. Gilead and later at Westminster Woods.

1963-1969 Rev. William Dye (associate pastor) William and Maude Dye retired as missionaries in India. Rev. Dye took over visitation to the sick. Maude came to the Sunday School classes regularly to tell the children stories about life in India. Dr. Dye, as he preferred to be called, conducted a series of Sunday evening studies about Eastern music and religion.

1966-1970 Rev. Elmer Podoll The last payment on the educational wing debt was made in May of 1967. A special Dedication Service was held on November 26, 1967. Bishop Donald Harvey Tippett gave the sermon, and the mortgage was burned. On September 30, 1968 a new division of the Kumdubbles was formed. Eventually named the Yungdubbles, it included the younger couples from the Kumdubbles group and hoped to attract new young couples in the church. For many years women of the church played organ meditations 20 minutes before church started. Some of those who contributed their talent unstintingly included Eunice Martinson, Ruth Christensen, Ruth Durst, Gertrude Roberts, and Grace Dahms.

In 1969 the Fireside Room was remodeled as a memorial to Ivan Roberts and Ronald Schultz. Also in 1969 the stained glass window of the shepherd was put in the sanctuary by the Wesleyan Service Guild in memory of Nellie Matthews.

1970-1974 Rev. William Dalton was a very learned man with a terrific wife, Tobina.

1974-1979 Rev. Wallace Gordon Riches Wally and Dallas' enthusiasm for Cursillo was catching. Our newsletter name was changed to "The Appleseed." The United Methodist Church and the Congregational Church formed the Burbank Heights housing project in 1975.

1975-1995 Rev. Donald Schilling (associate pastor) Our congregation voted to use $36,000 of the Williams' bequest to start Operating Getting It Together, a ministry to help troubled young people, and appointed Rev. Schilling to direct the program. Dee Schilling, an attorney, still provides low cost legal services for those who can't afford regular legal fees.

1979-1987 Rev. William Joseph Marx In 1981 our church was designated an historical building by the West Sonoma County Historical Society. It is the piece of property in Sebastopol that has been owned the longest by a single private owner.

For many years there had been water leakage around the south wall of the sanctuary. In 1980, the trustees, headed by Will Roberts, discovered that the wall was full of dry rot and unsafe. Some people felt we could not raise the money to repair it at an estimated cost of $100,000. In the end, due to the prodigious volunteer labor of Jim Henningsen, Charles Fellers and others, the repair was completed at a cost of $99,248. In March of 1985 the congregation was informed that the wood inside the dome of the bell tower, two pillars holding up the dome and the roof area above the bell were full of dry rot. The bell could not be used until this was fixed. $9,000 was raised to repair the dome, reinforce the bell supports and repair the plaster in the sanctuary.

1987-1994 Rev. Stanley Lloyd Simpson In 1988 the Outreach Committee began supporting a ministry to the women in both Sonoma County detention facilities. Twenty-five volunteers were involved in providing chapel services, educational opportunities, and peer support groups for women in jail.

1994-2001 Rev. Linda P. Snyder was our first woman pastor. Coming with an early childhood education background, Linda helped us revitalize our ministry to children and youth. In the fall of 1996, Vickie Glazier was hired to coordinate our youth program, followed by Candace Saxman in 2001.

2001-2005 Rev. Karen Paulsen came to us from Point Arena (although she already owned a home in Sebastopol). This is her second ministerial appointment. She brings strengths in social awareness and ecumenical unity. In the summer of 2003, we joined together with St. John's UMC (in Rohnert Park) and Forestville UMC in the hiring of Dana Greiner to lead a combined 3-church youth group which called itself CLAY (Christ Led Abiding Youth). Petaluma UMC youth joined in several months later, followed by Christ UMC in Santa Rosa in 2004. Each church rotated hosting the youth meetings on a monthly basis. In the summer of 2004, the front wall of Epworthian Hall was repaired - damaged drywall was replaced and repainted and the windows were replaced. Work was done by Ernie Bohn, Paul Schoch, Don Roberts, and Bill Davidson, all members of our congregation.

2005- Rev. Judith Stone came to us from the Silicon Valley area, bringing 26 years of pastoral experience. After receiving a degree in Art from UC Berkeley, she studied Theology and Art in Seminary, for a Masters Degree, intending to be an Art Therapist, but ending up as a Pastor. During the 26 years prior to her arrival here, she served at churches in Marin, Truckee, Reno, Chico, and the Los Gatos/Saratoga area.

During the summer and fall of 2006 the sanctuary roof was replaced, and the exterior of the buildings were repainted - desert tan for the body of the church buildings, a light cream color for the trim, a medium terra-cotta for accents on the trim and a deep terra-cotta for the beautiful dome. The roof and repainting were paid for by contributions from the congregation and from money left to the church by Alberta Adamson. Alberta and her husband had both been very involved with the Board of Trustees and the maintenance of the church facilities for present and future generations.

Also during the summer of 2006, the church council pledged $5000 to Habitat for Humanity in support of Habitat houses being built in the Sebastopol area in 2006 and 2007.


As Mildred Fredricks wrote in her history, "The true evaluation of a church is not made in figures. It is concerned with the lives of people." By this standard Sebastopol United Methodist Church has been a faithful witness for over 135 years!

-- Will and Leaf Roberts

updated by Lorna Blanc 2006

[back to top of page]