return to Current Event page

return to Homework page

Current Event

Lead Article:

Support Article #1:
The North American Trade Agreement
[in English and Spanish]

Support Article #2:
The Cild Labor Coalition:
an anti-child labor organization

return to the top of the page

 Current Event:

Bachman, S.L.. Young Workers in Mexico's Economy. U.S. News and World Report, 9-01-97

This article has several primary themes. The first, and most obvious, is the illegal hiring and overworking of minors in Mexico, and the moral boundaries these practices cross. The other is the economical impact it is having on the United States as well as Mexico, and the international violations the child labor is causing.

The central issues in this article revolve around the illegal hiring of youngsters (children, mostly under the legal working age of 14) on farms and in sweatshops, due to the incredibly low income rates of the worker's families and the lack of money to support education for children past the elementary school levels. These workplaces are usually farms, or very unsanitary and unsafely tended production factories (such as shoe-gluing factories and so forth), and for the most part have very unsafe and unhealthy working conditions. Young children working on the farms, tending to the vegetables (tomatoes, eggplant and corn for the most part) are regularly exposed to very dangerous chemicals, such as pesticides (many of which are illegal in the U.S.), and often have to handle the containers with their bare hands. Although the Mexican constitution clearly states that nobody under the age of 14 can legally be employed, this law is rarely payed attention to by employers as well as young people looking for work. Most of these minors come from very poor, very uneducated families, and most of their parents had themselves been working by the end of elementary school such as their children were now doing.

The other main issue in this article is the breaching of international contracts regarding child labor laws, mainly with the NAFTA (North America Free Trade Agreement). Mexico is constantly violating the laws and boundaries set by the NAFTA, and while several meetings have been held among authorities regarding the issue no significant changes appear to have been made. The main concerns are about the moral issues regarding Mexico's child labor, but another major concern is the economical impact it is having on farmers in the U.S. Farmers in states closer to the Mexican border are losing incredible amounts of money every year to the child laborers and their employers, who don't have to worry about complying to the restrictions of health codes and labor laws. In 1997 there were an estimated 2-4 million illegitimately employed children in the Mexican workforce.


  1. Do you think it is morally acceptable for children to be working fulltime shifts, rather than attending school, even if their family is unable to financially support themselves otherwise? Explain your answer.
  2. If you were in a position of authority, and the problem of child labor was apparent under your jurisdiction, what methods would you use to make sure that this problem was eliminated or dealt with justly?
  3. If you were a child working in horrible, unsanitary working conditions, but your familly could not even feed itself without the little financial support you provided them, what would you do?
  4. Do you think it is appropriate for the United States and NAFTA to be intruding on one of Mexico's significant economic institutions. Justify your answer.
  5. What do you think should be done by the governments of the world to ensure that illegal hiring of minors is prevented?

Supporting Links

North American Free Trade Agreement

The Child Labor Coalition: an anti-child labor organization

return to the top of the page


U.S. News & World Report, 09/01/97, Vol. 123 Issue 8, p40, 2p, 2c


NAFTA aims at curbing child labor, but it's rampant south of The border Along Mexico's northwest coast, Sinaloa State is lush with plantings of tomato, eggplant, and corn. Many of the vegetables and fruits grown there are destined for dinner tables across the United States. Indeed, the mountain-fringed region closely resembles rural California. But one thing is glaringly different: Many of the farm workers are children.

Their presence could draw the green fields of Sinaloa into the next trade dispute between the United States and Mexico. Under the framework of the North American Free Trade Agreement, a country that exploits child labor could face millions of dollars in fines not to mention severe public relations damage. Mexico is the only developing country in NAFTA, which has a labor side agreement that makes failure to enforce child labor laws a punishable offense. Yet working children in Mexico have attracted little attention.

That may be about to change. American labor unions and consumer activists have attacked child labor elsewhere through boycotts, pressure for corporate codes of conduct, and campaigns to affix labels on products not made by children. Last year, they exposed child labor at Central American and South Asian makers of clothing, rugs, and sporting gear, some sold under the names of celebrities like talk show host Kathie Lee Gifford.

Now the focus may be shifting to Mexico. Congress this fall will consider giving President Clinton "fast-track" authority to negotiate an expansion of NAFTA throughout the Americas. Labor unions and others plan to use the debate to voice complaints about the treaty.

Some Florida farmers and agricultural suppliers, for instance, are upset at having to compete against Mexican growers, who don't face tough or strictly enforced regulations on labor and the environment. The Fort Lauderdale-based Florida Farmers and Suppliers Coalition has sent most members of Congress a videotape comparing U.S. and Mexican farm practices. The group contends that Mexican use of contaminated water, pesticides banned in the United States, and children as laborers threatens consumers' health and U.S. jobs. "We are going to be doing what we can to make [Mexican child labor] part of the debate," promises Steve Trossman of the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, whose truckers and food packers fear job losses from Mexican competition.

On the job. The Mexican government says it is taking economic and educational measures to combat the practice of putting youngsters to work. Officials from Mexico, Canada, and the United States will meet in Ottawa in October to recommend ways to do that. Still, farm laborers younger than Mexico's legal working age of 14 are a common sight in the countryside. In the village of Villa Juarez, near the Sinaloan capital of Culiacan, 20 tomato-field workers recently gathered around a parked truck. Half were children. They included Marcos Antonio, 7, dressed in a ragged shirt and shorts. He and his family migrated to Villa Juarez from the poorer state of Guerrero; now he toils alongside his mother on the same crew. Why does he work? ''My father died," he says simply.

Mexican youth also can be found gluing shoes in workshops in Guanajuato State, stacking bricks in Durango, and lifting two or three times their body weight in produce at Mexico City's central market. Children who clean up toxic oil residues in Tabasco are in "the worst situation," says Eduardo Rodriguez Silva of UNICEF's Mexico City office. The work performed by many kids leaves them scarred, injured, or disabled. They usually come from poor and poorly educated families. Their parents are often ill, absent, or deceased and worked as youths themselves.

Estimates of the number of Mexican child laborers range from the government's 400,000 to UNICEF's 2 million to 4 million. The Mexican Constitution officially outlaws wage labor for children below age 14, and most modern Mexican factories are believed to screen out underage workers. But child labor persists in agriculture and small and family businesses.

Mexico claims nearly universal enrollment in elementary school, but povertyleads hundreds of thousands of children to drop out. Many who stay in school work part time. In Villa Juarez, the Henry Ford School 23, named for early support from Ford Motor Co., teaches children in morning and afternoon shifts. That allows them to work half time in vegetable processing plants or in the fields that surround the school. Yet some parents withdraw their children from school anyway.

The Secretariat for Social Development tries to keep elementary school pupils from dropping out as they migrate with their families to Sinaloa and other states. Mexico has recently funneled more money into such efforts, says UNICEF's Rodriguez. In August the government announced a program called El Progresa to offer poor families improved schooling, nutrition, and housing.

But social service agencies have yet to catch up with people like Crecensio Piochinto, a migrant to Sinaloa from Guerrero, who spoke with a reporter as he bathed in an agricultural canal with his wife and children, ages 10 and 12. The entire family works in the fields. Piochinto says his children aren't receiving an education because "there's no school here." Told that the Henry Ford School is just a few hundred yards away, he sighs, "Well, but I couldn't afford to send them to school."

Laws ignored. Meanwhile, the child labor laws remain widely unenforced. "

The reality of Mexico is that in many cases the Constitution isn't followed," notes Emilio Krieger Vazquez, a journalist and veteran campaigner for social causes. Labor inspectors who have the responsibility for spotting underage employees are overworked and underpaid, and the government allows favored companies and industries to get away with prohibited labor practices, say Mexican labor leaders.

Whether specific instances of child labor will ever result in NAFTA sanctions is doubtful. The three NAFTA governments or outside groups can initiate complaints on child labor, but so far, nobody has. Even if Mexico were officially found not to be enforcing child labor laws, it could not be fined more than $29.3 million in any given case, says the U.S. Labor Department. That's an insignificant shareof last year's $419 billion in trade among the three NAFTA countries.

Activists say little has come of past labor complaints under NAFTA: Mexico can avoid fines simply by showing an attempt to end an offense. Some activists instead believe that the way to force countries to curb child labor is to bar their child-made goods from the rich U.S. market. Sen. Tom Harkin, an Iowa Democrat, is sponsoring a bill to block such imports. Consumer groups are also lobbying Congress to label produce with its origin for consumers worried about food safety or foreign farming practices. ''I think if a company or a country knows that it will be losing money, then that forces them to change," says Linda Golodner, National Consumers League president and co-chair of the Child Labor Coalition, which includes more than 50 unions, public health schools, and religious organizations.

Golodner points to consumer actions against soccer ball manufacturers in Pakistan and garment factories in Bangladesh. The soccer ball makers agreed this spring to phase out their use of youngsters as ball stitchers after U.S. and European schoolchildren urged a boycott. In Bangladesh, clothing makers for such retailers as Wal-Mart agreed to move children out of factories and into school. The accord was reached after the threat of a U.S. boycott of Bangladeshi garments, launched by the Child Labor Coalition. Now, activists say, it's Mexico's turn to face the scrutiny of its American customers.

By S.L. Bachman

Copyright of U.S. News & World Report is the property of US News & World Report and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.


return to Current Event page

return to the top of the page

return to Homework page